Searching over 5,500,000 cases.

Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.

Doria v. Bayonne Hospital

June 27, 2008


On appeal from the Division of Workers' Compensation, 1997-7608, 1998-31950, 2000-15341.

Per curiam.


Argued May 28, 2008

Before Judges Coburn, Chambers and Waugh.

Petitioner Orsola Doria appeals the denial of her claim for total permanent disability set forth in her two petitions for workers' compensation benefits. We find that the findings of the judge of compensation, rejecting her claims for total permanent disability and finding her partial disability of thirty percent due to the accident set forth in her first petition, are supported by substantial evidence, and affirm. We remand solely for resolution of the dispute regarding payment of medical bills.

The record indicates that Doria, born in 1939, had worked in a sewing factory for thirty-five years; she testified that she was exposed to dust and did some lifting when working there. In 1991, she became employed by respondent Bayonne Hospital as a housekeeper. In that capacity, she did cleaning, including mopping the floors, cleaning the bathrooms, changing the bedding, and dusting. This work involved lifting and bending and exposure to cleaning chemicals and dust.

Doria filed two workers' compensation petitions that are the subject of this appeal. The first claim petition (1997-007608) filed on October 11, 1996, arose out of an accident that took place on May 23, 1996, when a ceiling tile fell on her head while she was working at Bayonne Hospital. Doria claimed to be totally and permanently disabled from this accident, asserting orthopedic, neurological, psychiatric, and internal injuries.

The second claim petition (1998-031950), filed on September 4, 1998, alleged occupational disability. In that petition, Doria alleged that she was permanently and totally disabled due to "[o]ccupational exposure to dust, fumes, pulmonary irritants, bending, lifting, repeated manipulations, standing, stress, strain, adverse environment causing occupational conditions and diseases." She alleged impairment of her "chest, lungs, nose, throat, neck, back, knees, arthritis, orthopedic system, hypertension, cardiovascular system, nervous system, neurosis and complications arising therefrom." Her related claim to the Second Injury Fund for occupational exposure was filed on October 5, 1998.

The hearing before the workers' compensation judge spanned eight days. In addition to her own testimony, Doria presented the testimony of three doctors. Dr. I. Ahmad, an orthopedist, diagnosed Doria with a spinal sprain, arthritis and myositis, and concluded that she was totally disabled. Dr. Robert Latimer, a psychiatrist, found that she suffered from post-concussion syndrome, with chronic headaches, fatigue, and depression, and that she had a related adjustment disorder problem because she could not work. He found her totally and permanently disabled. Dr. Sidney Friedman, an internist, found that she had chronic bronchitis of the non-obstructive type and attributed thirty percent partial total disability due to that condition. He attributed twenty percent partial total disability to her hypertension with cardiac disease.

The record also included other medical records and reports including the August 12, 1996, report of Dr. Gregory D. Anselmi, M.D., a neurologist who treated Doria after the ceiling tile accident. In that report, he noted his impression that she suffered a cerebral concussion, post-concussive syndrome, and whiplash injury with possible cervical radiculopathy.

The defense presented the testimony of three doctors who had examined Doria. Dr. Adam Rowen, an internist and pulmonary expert, concluded Doria did not have any pulmonary disability. Dr. Terry Tuchin, a psychiatrist, agreed that Doria suffered post-concussion syndrome from the May 23, 1996, accident, but attributed to Doria only two and one-half percent disability. He did not find her permanently and totally disabled. Dr. Ralph R. Ricciardi, an orthopedist, found no permanent disability. In a lengthy decision placed on the record on April 9, 2007, the judge of compensation accepted some of the medical testimony offered by Doria and accepted some of the medical testimony offered by respondent. He found Doria thirty percent totally disabled on the ceiling tile accident claim, making the following allocation: ten percent partial total disability for cerebral concussion; ten percent partial total disability for post-concussion syndrome; and ten percent partial total disability for cervical sprain. He found that Doria had failed to meet her burden to prove her claim of occupational exposure and that claim was dismissed. Since Doria had failed to prove total disability, the related Second Injury Fund claim was also dismissed. The judge also ordered that Doria provide reimbursement of the temporary disability lien in the sum of $7,065.19. He did not address the dispute regarding unpaid medical bills.

Doria raises the following issues on appeal:



Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.