Searching over 5,500,000 cases.


searching
Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Official citation and/or docket number and footnotes (if any) for this case available with purchase.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.

UNITED STATES v. JACOBS

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY


April 5, 1957

UNITED STATES of America, Plaintiff,
v.
Josephine E. JACOBS, Administratrix of the Estate of Michael S. Jacobs, Deceased; Twentieth Century Sporting Club, Incorporated, Defendants

The opinion of the court was delivered by: FORMAN

In the first count of the complaint in this case, as amended, the plaintiff, the United States of America, alleges that the Commissioner of Internal Revenue assessed the defendant, Twentieth Century Sporting Club, Incorporated, a New York corporation (hereinafter called Twentieth Century), on July 3, 1952, for the deficiency in its 1946 income, excess profits and declared value excess profit taxes in the amount of $ 21,086.92, and $ 100,118.83, plus interest, and on February 19, 1953, for a like deficiency in the amount of $ 13,500.87 for the year 1948, plus interest, or an aggregate of $ 134,706.12; that the said defendant Twentieth Century is entitled to credit for $ 39,973.05 collected against the said assessments by virtue of plaintiff's tax levy, leaving a balance due of $ 94,733.57 together with interest; and that the late Michael S. Jacobs, prior to his death was, and his estate, or which the defendant Josephine E. Jacobs is administratrix, now is, indebted to the said defendant Twentieth Century in the sum of $ 173,701.71, which debt is subject to the tax liens arising out of the said assessments on defendant Twentieth Century's property and rights to property in the sum of $ 94,733.57, as aforesaid.

In the second count of the complaint, in the form of an amendment thereto, the plaintiff alleges that during and after the period 1943 to 1947 the said Michael S. Jacobs was a shareholder and an officer and director of the defendant Twentieth Century; that during the said period 1943 to 1947 the defendant Twentieth Century made a series of loans to him totaling $ 173,701.71; that the said Michael S. Jacobs in his capacity as an officer and director of the defendant Twentieth Century knew and assented to the making of the said loans on which there is, as alleged, a balance of $ 154,701.71 still due; that the assessments and levies were made on the defendant Twentieth Century, as described in the first count of the complaint, leaving an unpaid balance of $ 94,733.57 still due and owing by Twentieth Century; that under the provisions of the New York Stock Corporation Law, McK.Consol. Laws, c. 59, Section 59, the said Michael S. Jacobs was, and his estate now is, personally liable for the corporate tax debt, which debt arose prior to the repayment of the above mentioned loans; that the liability of the estate of Michael S. Jacobs to the plaintiff United States is direct and not derivative and that it is not barred from asserting such liability under the New York statute by any state statute of limitations.

 Plaintiff demands that the merits of all claims and liens upon the alleged debt of Michael S. Jacobs be finally determined and that the court order a distribution according to the findings of the court in respect to the interest of the parties herein.

 The defendant Josephine E. Jacobs, Administratrix of the Estate of Michael S. Jacobs, deceased, in probate proceedings pending in the Monmouth County (New Jersey) Surrogate's Court, contends in her motion for summary judgment that the debts alleged to be owing from Michael S. Jacobs and his estate to Twentieth Century are barred by the statute of limitations; that the United States has no greater rights with respect to these alleged debts than the defendant Twentieth Century, and that the United States did not acquire title to these debts prior to the expiration of six years from the respective dates on which they were incurred.

 For the purpose of this motion the parties have stipulated facts as noted in the margin hereof. *fn1"

  The plaintiff resists the defendant's motion on the ground that on July 11, 1952 and March 23, 1953, the dates for which the plaintiff's liens for taxes arose, the decedent Michael S. Jacobs, was indebted to Twentieth Century and such debt was enforceable under the New York law. Exhibit 'A' referred to in paragraph 3 of the stipulation (Note 1) is a ledger account of Twentieth Century with Michael S. Jacobs in which he is debited with 16 items aggregating $ 170,000, under dates and amounts as follows: Date Debits 1943 Apr 19 $ 20,000.00 May 12 10,000.00 1944 Sept 6 10,000.00 1945 Mar 23 9,000.00 " 23 1,000.00 Aug 28 12,000.00 Dec 4 10,000.00 1946 May 1 10,000.00 " 7 25,000.00 July 9 20,000.00 " 10 5,000.00 " 22 3,000.00 Sept 6 10,000.00 Dec 21 9,000.00 1947 Jan 4 10,000.00 Aug 9 6,000.00

19570405

© 1992-2004 VersusLaw Inc.



Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Official citation and/or docket number and footnotes (if any) for this case available with purchase.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.