Searching over 5,500,000 cases.


searching
Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.

Jancisin v. H.F. Realty Co.

Decided: June 5, 1950.

NICHOLAS JANCISIN AND JULIA JANCISIN, HIS WIFE, PLAINTIFFS,
v.
H.F. REALTY COMPANY, INC., ET AL., DEFENDANTS



Grimshaw, J.s.c.

Grimshaw

[8 NJSuper Page 569] Plaintiffs are the owners of a plot of ground on the easterly side of Lexington Avenue in the City of Clifton. Upon this plot there is erected a two-family house. The house is located on the plot in such a position as to leave a strip of land approximately 8 feet wide between the house and the southerly boundary line of plaintiffs' property. The defendant corporation owns the plot adjoining that of the plaintiffs on the south. On the front of defendant's plot and occupying practically its entire width is a brick apartment and store building. In the rear of the apartment house and also on defendant's property there is a substantial concrete building and a block of small garages. The concrete building has been used at different times as a tinsmith's shop

and a storage garage. Latterly it has been used as a furniture warehouse. The garages are rented to the tenants of the apartment house.

It does not appear when plaintiffs' house was erected. The garages and concrete building were built in 1924 and the apartment house in 1927. Since 1924, except as herein noted, the 8-foot strip on the southerly side of plaintiffs' house has been used continuously as a means of access to the concrete building and garages. Since 1927 when the apartment house was erected, the 8-foot strip has been the only means of access to the buildings in the rear of defendant's property. The strip has the appearance of a driveway. There is no curb in front of it. And during part of the period during which it has been used there were concrete ribbons upon it such as are commonly used in driveways. Recently these ribbons of concrete have been broken up by the passage of vehicles.

In 1941, the tenant in the house now owned by the plaintiffs, sought to bar access to the 8-foot strip. Stakes were placed at intervals but were removed after several days upon threat of court action. After plaintiffs acquired title to their property, they, too, placed barriers on the strip which were removed by defendant's agents within a matter of hours. With these exceptions the strip has been used openly and continuously as a driveway since 1924. The automobiles of the tenants of the garages pass over it daily. Trucks delivering coal to the apartment house and those going to the warehouse have used it.

In 1922, one Zachary Chitirkin acquired title to the plot now owned by the defendant. In 1924 he acquired the plot now owned by the plaintiffs, under the name of Chetirkin. In January of 1927 he conveyed the southerly plot to Johanna Chitirkin and in February of the same year he conveyed to her the northerly plot under the name of Chetirkin.

On July 11, 1927, Johanna Chitirkin mortgaged the property now owned by the defendant to the Perfection Building and Loan Association. Thereafter on December 8, 1927, she executed a second mortgage covering the same property to

Barnet Beskin and Hyman Seitzman. Included in the description was the following:

"Together with a plot of ground 8 feet in width on Lexington Avenue and 100 feet in depth adjoining the premises hereinafter mentioned on the north thereof for the purposes hereinafter mentioned."

Then, following a description of the 8-foot strip appears the following:

"The last described premises are for the use only as a driveway to be used in common, with the premises first above described and the premises adjoining to the north."

The mortgage given to the Perfection Building and Loan Association was subsequently foreclosed. In the sheriff's deed, the right of way was included. Thereafter by mesne conveyances, all of which included the right of way, title was acquired by the defendant. On May 4, 1925, Johanna Chetirkin conveyed the property now owned by the plaintiffs to Olga Chetirkin, ...


Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.