Searching over 5,500,000 cases.


searching
Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Official citation and/or docket number and footnotes (if any) for this case available with purchase.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.

Newark and Essex Building Corp. v. City of Newark

New Jersey Supreme Court


Decided: April 11, 1945.

NEWARK AND ESSEX BUILDING CORPORATION, A NEW JERSEY CORPORATION, PROSECUTOR,
v.
CITY OF NEWARK, A MUNICIPAL CORPORATION, ET AL., RESPONDENTS

On certiorari.

For the prosecutor, Harry Schaffer.

For the City of Newark, Philip J. Schotland and Vincent J. Casale.

Before Justices Case, Bodine and Porter.

Bodine

[132 NJL Page 575]

The opinion of the court was delivered by

BODINE, J. This is a tax case. It involves taxes for the year 1942. The property in question is the large store and office building occupying a large tract of land situate at 736-753 Broad Street in the City of Newark.

On January 4th, 1944, the State Board of Tax Appeals rendered a judgment reducing the assessment to $5,760,500, allocated $1,560,500 to land and $4,200,000 to building.

Certiorari was allowed.

Franklin Hannoch, prosecutor's expert, testified before the State Board that the true value of the property as of the assessing date as between a willing buyer and a willing seller, neither compelled to buy or sell, was $4,727,000; he allocated $1,527,000 to land and $3,200,000 to building.

The testimony of Mr. Hannoch shows that he valued the property in the following manner: the gross rentals, if fully occupied would be $957,502 and from this figure, although actual vacancies amounted to $228,000 and the building had a vacancy history of 35 to 40 per cent. from 1930 to 1942, there was deducted for vacancies 10 per cent. or $95,750, which left an effective gross income of $861,752. From this figure deducting $310,995, the actual operating expenses for the taxable year (excluding taxes, interest on mortgage and depreciation), left a net income of $550,747 before depreciation and taxes. He felt that the amount required to support a land value of $1,527,000 was 5 per cent. for interest and 5.3 per cent. for taxes, or $157,281. Deducting this sum from the net income left $393,466 to apply to the building. Capitalizing the building at 5 per cent. for interest, 5.3 per cent. for taxes and 2 per cent. for depreciation resulted in a building value of $3,200,000.

A careful review of all the other evidence satisfies us that the views of Mr. Hannoch are persuasive.

The National Newark and Essex Banking Company pays a rent in excess of that paid for similar premises. In determining true value between a willing seller and a willing buyer, replacement cost and income return are not the sole criterion. All the factors considered, we can only conclude that the assessment

[132 NJL Page 576]

should be reduced to comply with the views expressed by Mr. Hannoch.

The judgment is reversed.

19450411


Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Official citation and/or docket number and footnotes (if any) for this case available with purchase.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.